If you are thinking of selecting a new roof for your house or commercial building, you may be wondering which type is the best choice. Fortunately, many options are available when considering the benefits and drawbacks of various roofing materials. Knowing this gives you leverage to consider those options and eventually arrive at a decision based on facts. 

The decision you will make regarding the type of roofing material can greatly affect your construction’s look, comfort, and cost. It also affects the ensuing maintenance, energy, and immediate construction costs. 

People still tend to choose asphalt-based shingles because of the lesser cost and better reliability standards. Although options have increased in the past few years, this one is still considered to be a viable option. 

Among the other options, metal roofs come into mind considering the benefits they provide. We have compiled all the relevant information regarding metal vs shingle roofing, currently the two best roofing options, to help  make your choice easier.

Considerations when selecting roofing material 

Before discussing the pros and cons of metal vs shingle roofing, let us shed some light on a few factors that you should consider when choosing your roofing material. The architectural style and surroundings are essential in determining which materials are suitable, be it asphalt shingles for versatility or metal roofing for historic homes. 

Additional factors for making a well-rounded roofing decision include performance, design, underlayments, and energy efficiency. By carefully weighing these factors, you can choose a long-lasting, aesthetically pleasing, cost-effective roof that suits your needs.

Metal Roofing

Metal roofing has gained a lot of popularity in recent years due to its exceptional durability and aesthetically pleasing appearance. These types of roofs can be made from copper, steel, or aluminum. This provides several advantages for homeowners, making them an appealing option. 

Advantages

Let’s first examine the advantages of this roofing material in more detail.

Highly Resistant

Metal roofing effectively repels strong winds, hail, and other severe weather events. They are perfect for areas subject to severe weather because they do not decay or get split. They are also the least likely to catch fire because they are typically Class A fire-rated and non-combustible. 

This is crucial in wildfire-prone areas because a metal roof is much less likely to catch fire if hot ashes fall on it than shingle roofing would. Hence if you are a resident in such an area, opting for top-quality metal roofing would be highly valuable. 

Sustainable and Energy Efficient

Metal roofing is reusable at the end of its lifespan and frequently constructed from recycled materials. It is, therefore, a sustainable choice for homeowners who prioritize protecting the environment. Apart from being environmentally friendly, metal roofing materials reflect solar heat, lowering how much heat your home absorbs. 

This may result in lowering cooling costs, particularly in areas with warmer climates. Also, some metal roofs have coatings that improve their heat rejection effectiveness, lowering energy usage even more. This overall makes them not only nature-friendly but energy efficient as well.

Highly Durable

Source: Pixabay

Metal roofs are well known for having an exceptionally long lifespan. They ought to last for as long as fifty years with regular maintenance, outlasting conventional shingle roofs by a huge margin. 

Such a long duration is possible due to their ability to absorb less moisture. To add to it, they have placement clips or drilled screw apertures that permit the metal to move with variations in temperature without eventually tearing apart.

Diverse Color Options

When analyzing metal vs shingle roofing, the one thing that appeals to any customer is the variety of color options. Colors are also significant for managing energy efficiency. Metal roofs overtake shingle roofing in this regard, as they can be found in almost any color. 

Top-notch paint warranties back these roofs, due to which there is a lot of diversity of color choices. These paints undergo extensive natural testing to guarantee they can last decades.

Disadvantages

Every roofing material has some drawbacks. Even though metal roofs have many advantages, homeowners must also be aware of the potential cons associated with them. Let’s talk about some flaws of metal roofs. 

Being Noisy

Many homeowners have shared the concern that metal roofs get pretty loud when there is a lot of rain or hail. Compared to lighter materials like asphalt shingles, metal can be significantly noisier. 

However, good underlayment and insulation can reduce this noise if such an issue arises. Attic insulation can also be increased, but it might raise costs. 

Being Expensive

Compared to shingle roofing, metal roofing typically has a higher upfront price. Labor prices are also higher as technical expertise is a little rare in the workforce. The tools required to finish the job may also be more expensive in addition to the higher cost of the materials themselves. 

Despite the cost issues, it is an investment for the future that pays off over time, given its longevity and durability.

Having Restricted Technical Expertise

Skilled roofing experts are essential for the correct installation of roofing elements. As we are differentiating between metal vs shingle roofing, metal roof installers are more challenging to find than those who install shingles. 

Having Costly Coverage

We know that metal roofing is costly and that it needs maintenance at regular intervals. Any damage could become extremely expensive, which insurance companies might not cover which is a lot different when compared to the less costly shingles. 

Shingle Roofing

The most common type of roofing in many residential areas is shingle roofing, referred to as asphalt roofing. It has been a popular option for decades because of its timeless appearance and several advantages. 

You can find shingle roofs everywhere, as these roofs were standard for every household for a long while before metal roofing started becoming popular.

Advantages

There are undoubtedly many advantages to installing a shingle roof.  Let’s explore some of the benefits in more detail.

Economically Viable

Shingle roofing is typically less expensive than metal roofs, making it a cost-effective choice for homeowners. The cheaper upfront cost may be alluring for individuals on a tight budget. 

No complex Installation

Shingle roofs are comparatively quick and more straightforward to install than metal roofs. This can cut down on labor costs and lessen how much your daily routine will be disturbed during the installation process. As discussed earlier, metal roofing has a complex installation procedure. Many skilled laborers are required, adding extra costs, effort, and time. 

Repair Costs

Source: Pixabay

Shingle roofs are often simple to repair in case of damage. You would very rarely need to replace the entire roof. You can save ample time and money by replacing only a few shingles. 

Many shingles can be fixed with fewer materials by removing them one at a time close to the fault. With metal roofing, since the complete panels are all joined together and more challenging to replace one at a time, it is more complicated and expensive.

Coastal Compatibility

While there is a lot of debate about metal vs shingle roofing installation in coastal areas, it is no secret that a steel roof warranty is typically not provided. Coastline residential areas are accustomed to the wind as well. If shingles are damaged by wind, they are lighter and more straightforward to replace. 

This is especially true of asphalt or composite shingles. In light of this, it’s critical to understand the region in which your project is situated and the wind rating required for your roof system based on that location. 

Disadvantages

Shingle roofing is similar to other building materials; it also has benefits and drawbacks.

Average Longevity

When compared to metal roofs, it is known that these roofs have a shorter life span. Compared to an average of 50 years of metallic roofing, shingle roofs usually last for about 30 years on average. Apart from this, life expectancy repair and routine maintenance are also required more than that for metal roofs. 

Risk Prone

Many residential owners have highlighted the vulnerability of shingle roofs during harsh weather conditions. Be it on a scorching day, stronger winds, or rain, a hot day can undoubtedly cause their color to fade away. 

The discoloration is usually considered the first sign that your roofing shingles are getting damaged. Additionally, they could be prone to the growth of moss and algae, necessitating urgency in routine upkeep. These issues can certainly become costly over time. 

Being Less Recyclable

Around 11 million tons of asphalt shingles are discarded every year. Although shingles are recyclable, the results are negligible compared to metal roofing. With so many shingles ending up in landfills more consumers and contractors need to be aware that shingles should be disposed of responsibly.

Price Variation

Oil (petroleum) is the main component of asphalt shingles. Due to this result, the price of shingles can change significantly depending on the price of a barrel of crude oil. Also, oil-based items are typically made from non-renewable resources and cannot be recycled. 

Fungal Issues

Source: Pixabay

If your shingled roof has shaded areas, you can expect fungus to be a concern soon enough. You must get the roofing inspected and cleaned at regular intervals. Routine cleaning shouldn’t harm your roof and can help keep the fungal attack at bay. If not, it’s best to seek assistance from a professional roofing company to avoid hurting your asphalt shingles or limiting their lifespan.

In-efficient when rejecting heat

Unfortunately, asphalt shingle roofing material is not recommended if you are considering a more efficient energy option. Some roofing options are more energy efficient than others. However, replacing an older asphalt shingle roof with a new one could help you make your home more energy-efficient. Generally speaking, asphalt shingles are only sometimes considered the most energy-efficient option. 

Considering Aesthetics and Architecture

It’s essential to consider how the roofing material will blend in with your house’s overall design and architecture when selecting a roofing material.

Aesthetics

Metal roofing frequently has a sleek, contemporary look that fits very well with modern or industrial-style homes. It can be found in various colors and finishes to suit your style preferences. 

Shingle roofing, on the other hand, has a more conventional and timeless appearance, making it a popular option for a variety of architectural types.

Architectural Compatibility

When deciding between metal and shingle roofing, consider the home’s architectural design. Metal roofs complement architectural styles that emphasize straight lines and contemporary components. On the other hand, shingle roofs are frequently a flexible alternative that can complement a variety of architectural types.

Metal vs. Shingle Roofing. Which is the Better Option?

Source: Pixabay

When comparing metal vs shingle roofing, considering the pros and cons we have outlined above, which should you choose?

Both are good. Your requirements will eventually determine your choice.

Outstanding longevity, toughness, energy efficiency, and environmental sustainability are all features of metal roofing. It is the best option for those looking for a long-term investment and defense against extreme weather. 

As opposed to this, shingle roofing is more reasonably priced and simpler to install. It is a well-liked option for households on a tight budget that value adaptability and repairability. The most incredible choice ultimately comes down to your unique requirements, financial constraints, and personal preferences.

Some questions you should ask while choosing a suitable roofing material include:

• What budget do I have? Can I spend a higher amount?
• Is it important for me to use recycled material?
• Do I reside in a region that experiences severe weather events?
• How much time will I spend looking for roofing contractors?

Conclusion

A roof installation requires a significant financial investment. To feel confident and content with your chosen roof, we need you to be well-educated about your options. The decision depends on your specific needs, budget, and personal preferences. 

Moreover, consulting a professional roofing contractor can help you make an informed decision based on your circumstances. 

Remember to consider your home’s architectural style, the climate of the area in which it’s located, and long-term goals when selecting the roofing material that best suits your needs.